Discrimination in the air

Gender discrimination is alive and kicking, even in the spaces where it seems absent.
Capt. Lynn Rippelmeyer source: www.seaboardairlines.org

Last July, American Airlines flight 909 was about the take-off from Miami heading to Buenos Aires, Argentina. It is a red-eye flight, departs at midnight. Families gather to doze together with oversized stuffed animals. People escape the winter in South America to rejoice with thousands of tourists in Florida. They have a tan, are a little broke, but in general, are happy. This is why it was surprising to read the news about a group of passengers who de-boarded the plane, delaying their departure for about two hours. The reason: the pilot and co-pilot flying that night were women.

When the announcement was made in Spanish, referring to the two female pilots, the commotion began. A number of passengers insisted on de-boarding the plane. The subsequent removal of their luggage caused a long delay.

It was not due to a safety issue or a delayed connecting flight. The reason why this happened was because of prevalent sexism. The all-women crew were assessed differently, as if being a woman was a liability that justified a different kind of scrutiny regarding ability or capacity. This is a painful reminder of how ingrained and wired gender inequality is, and the challenging cultural and social barriers that women face in all spheres of life.

Today, women make less money than men at equal level jobs, they are victims of violence for the mere fact of being women, and they have to deal with the social expectations of performing flawlessly at work, at home, and in life. Women struggle constantly to be treated as full human beings, fighting institutions and laws dominated by men that seek to limit their basic rights, including decisions about their own bodies. In spite of the staunch fight that women put up every day, the pervasive force of discrimination continues to plague our society.

Unfortunately, this situation was not an isolated case. Historically, women pilots have faced sexism, prejudice, and marginalization. The experiences are numerous and common knowledge for people in the aeronautic industry. What Helen Richey – the first commercial pilot in the U.S.- faced in the 1930s is not so different from the experiences of women who dare to challenge the status quo and pursue a dream. A right every person should have regardless of their sex, sexual orientation, or gender identity.

The International Society of Women Air Pilots (ISA) estimates that there are around “4000 female airline pilots out of 130,000 worldwide”, representing barely 3 percent. This rate is higher in the U.S. at 6 percent. The odds of having a female pilot on your flight are extremely low, but the chances of them facing blunt discrimination are still high. In order to eradicate these harmful practices and behaviors is fundamental to make them visible. In creating awareness about how discrimination manifests, each of us is able to act and speak up.

To contribute to this effort, the outstanding women at ISA shared with Defying Gender Roles some of their own stories, as a way to generate reflection on how gender inequality manifest in this industry but also as a reminder of the challenges that lay ahead in the quest for equality.

“747 captain for Northwest Airlines: we had men on some flights who deplaned when they saw ladies in the cockpit. We just shook our heads in amazement. Unfortunately, it is still going on, but it is their loss for being so clueless and close minded. They arrive at their destination late and probably for much more money!”

“There was a time, hard to believe but true, when Alaska airlines management allowed good customers to call corporate and find out which flights were scheduled with female pilots before booking. A complaint filed by the women pilots put an end to that. Unbelievable. Just the security issues of releasing that info is appalling. It could certainly have put the women pilots in jeopardy. Names of crew members are never made publicly available prior to a flight”

“It happens all over the world! I flew for a regional airline in South Africa, and on one of the legs we also had a man remove himself from the flight after seeing that the captain and first officer were both blonde females. We both honestly couldn’t have been bothered, as the way we saw it, we were going to be home relaxing and he would still need to get there, not guaranteed that his next flight would be any different. Sad but true in today’s world!”

“When I was the captain on a 747, a passenger complained as we were taxiing out that he wanted off the plane when the flight attendants announced I was the captain. He was throwing a fit so they asked me to come talk to him. We pulled over to the side of the taxi way and I went downstairs to have a chat. I said I was surprised that he waited this long to complain. I made quite a few announcements before we left the gate, introducing myself as the captain. He said, “with a female voice anyone would think it’s one of the flight attendants – So, there’s a flight attendant captain, now, I guess.” I said, “No, I’m the pilot Captain. There is no flight attendant captain. Now if you don’t want to be here, I don’t want you here, and the flight attendants and other passengers sure don’t want you here, so we can do all of us a favor and take you back to the gate. However, I am going to have to explain to the other four-hundred passengers, ground control, and our gate agents why we are returning, so I need your name. OK with you?” He said, “Well, I guess you got the training and are qualified”. I just stared at him. “Does that mean you’re going to sit here quietly and not cause my flight attendants anymore trouble?” Him, “I guess”. Me. “I want more than I guess. I want a Yes, Ma’am.” Him. “yes, ma’am”. And, so we continued. They tell me he didn’t say another thing”

“Ba3100 -Jetsteam- from MDT (Pennsylvania) to EWR (Newark). Female captain and I were doing triple EWR turns. On the first one, a male passenger saw me, got on the plane, saw the captain and got off the plane. Told the agent he’d take the next flight. The agent and I couldn’t look at each other or we would have started laughing! She also knew that the all-female crew was flying the next two EWR flight”

“Years ago Northwest Airlines (NW) staged a flight into Osaka with three women pilots on the DC10. I heard that bookings on NW dropped by 1/3 after the story aired in Japan. Complete backfire. Of course this could be a myth! Personally, when I was a 747 captain, the South East Asia mechanics would address the copilot instead of me. The copilot would look at me, I would answer the question, and he would repeat it back to the mechanic! By 2004, the Japanese mechanics would not do that…they were too professional and knew who the captain was”.

After you have read these stories, ask yourself: Would this happen to a man?

The experiences above are just a sample of the many challenges women face in their quest to be treated as equal. In sharing their stories, they are making evident how gender inequality permeates and limits their experience in life. These women challenge outdated, harmful gender norms and roles with strength and courage. But change only is possible if we all commit to stand together against these practices at the workplace, the schools, and at home. They are doing their part of the deal, now it is up to us to join them in their struggle against discrimination.

Sebastián Molano

Sebastián Molano is a Colombian gender specialist and development worker living in Boston. Currently, he consults for different NGO's on how to promote gender justice and engage men and boys in development projects. You can check here his TEDx Talk in gender isses: [a href="http://bit.ly/TEDxTalk-DefyinGendeRoles"]http://bit.ly/TEDxTalk-DefyinGendeRoles[/a] With the support of his awesome life partner/wife, Sebastián writes about the need to engage men and women in a needed, healthy discussion about new and liberating re-configuration of gender roles. He leads Defying Gender Roles a multi-lingual group that seeks to engage men and women in how to challenge harmful prevailing gender norms and roles. Check it out: http://defyingenderoles.org/
8 Comments on this post.
  • Karlene Petitt
    12 October 2016 at 4:03 am
    Leave a Reply

    Sebastián Thank you for sharing this post. There are numerous issues occurring in the world today, where women who have applied for airline jobs are asked questions during the interview process that challenge their dedication to the job because they worked around the task of raising children while earning a college degree, or stayed at home for a high risk birth, or were needed at home for a child that wasn’t thriving and how they did not appear as “captain material”. Not to mention the women who are being challenged for stability because they are questioning safety issues and “hurting” male egos within flight operations. Awareness is a key. We have a long way to go, but there are many men and women who applaud your efforts.

    • Sebastián Molano
      Sebastian Molano
      25 October 2016 at 7:17 pm
      Leave a Reply

      Thank you, Karlene for your comments and your insights. These are pressing issues and I am happy to be able to make them visible.

  • Kathy
    12 October 2016 at 4:10 am
    Leave a Reply

    Thanks Sebastian! Great article. Thanks for helping to raise awareness on this issue. Kathy McCullough ISA+21 Communications Chairwoman

    • pam perdue
      12 October 2016 at 11:04 pm
      Leave a Reply

      great article!

      • Sebastián Molano
        Sebastian Molano
        25 October 2016 at 7:18 pm
        Leave a Reply

        Thank you Pam for your comment and reading the article!

    • Sebastián Molano
      Sebastian Molano
      25 October 2016 at 7:18 pm
      Leave a Reply

      Thank you Kathy and all the women at ISA+21. You are the ones fighting patriarchy every day!

  • Pete
    15 October 2016 at 6:17 am
    Leave a Reply

    Great article, especially because it was written by a man. It’s critical that males speak out on behalf of women, that whites speak out in support of people of color. We’re all part of the human race–even women!:-) Thanks, Sebastian.

    • Sebastián Molano
      Sebastian Molano
      25 October 2016 at 7:20 pm
      Leave a Reply

      Thanks, Pete. As men, we have the obligation to speak up. We need to make sure we do not remind silent. Always making sure that we are allies in the struggle and not making the struggle about ourselves. I am very happy to see more men involved and engaged in gender issues!

    Leave a Reply




    • The thin line between fanaticism and sin

      In the early hours of the morning of 21 February 2017 in El Cortezal, a small quiet town in the Northeast of Nicaragua, Vilma Tujillo, a 25-year old mother...
    • Anti-gay, pro transgender

      Most people would associate Iran and Afghanistan with a religious fundamentalism that goes completely against the realities of transsexuality, transgenderism and homosexuality. And while it is true that both...
    • Why men?

      “I have had to interrogate masculinity, which I think doesn’t happen enough. The toxic privileges that come with being a man don’t define me, but I have to be...
    • Can I be a feminist and still go to Iran?

      Two events of particular importance took place last week: the opening of the Women’s World Chess Championship and an official visit by Swedish EU Affairs and Trade Minister Ann...