Water in Detroit: a matter of Human Rights

It all began with the bankruptcy of the city of Detroit, officially filed last year on July 18, the largest of its kind in U.S. history. The  city, once known as the...
Water Photo: World Bank/Allison Kwesell
Photo: World Bank/Allison Kwesell

It all began with the bankruptcy of the city of Detroit, officially filed last year on July 18, the largest of its kind in U.S. history. The  city, once known as the capital of automobile industry, suffered, like many other cities in the US and all over the world, the effects of the economic crisis, together with an unprecedented depopulation. Between 2000 and 2010 the city’s population fell by 25 percent, changing its ranking from the nation’s 10th largest city to the 18th.  In 2013, the city had a population of 701,000, more than a 60 percent drop down from a peak population of over 1.8 million at the 1950 census, indicating a serious and long-running decline of Detroit’s economic strength.

This serious disproportion between a city – with its infrastructures and services – built for a much larger population and the actual abandonment and tremendous poverty (nearly 40 percent of residents now live below the federal poverty line), created ground for a terrible choice: as part of its “money-generating scheme” and cutting debt strategy, the Detroit City Council backed the decision by the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD) to disconnect water services from households which have not paid bills in the past two months.

DWSD states that nearly half of its customers haven’t been paying their water bills leaving the public utility with some $90 million in debt: though the decision to cut off water to around 3,000 customers per week since last June. As a result, some 27,000 households have had their water services disconnected so far this year, left without water to drink, cook and basic sanitation.

Protests in Detroit. Credits: Joshua Lott/Getty Images

Protests in Detroit.
Credits: Joshua Lott/Getty Images

Activists in Detroit had appealed to the UN for assistance in stopping the practice in the city, claiming also that the increasing in water rates, justified by the DWSD with higher costs of leakage in ageing pipes, worsened the situation.

The answer by the UN came on October 20, at the end of a two-day visit to Detroit by the Special Rapporteur on the Human Right to Water and Sanitation, Catarina de Albuquerque, and the Special Rapporteur on the Human Right to Adequate Housing, Leilani Farha.

“It is contrary to human rights to disconnect water from people who simply do not have the means to pay their bills,” said Ms. de Albuquerque.

The press release pointed out that due to high poverty and unemployment rates, relatively expensive water bills in Detroit are unaffordable for a significant portion of the population, especially the most vulnerable and poorest” of the city’s population which were being disproportionately affected, including a predominant number of African Americans. In addition, the experts noted, repeated cases of gross errors on water bills have been reported which are also used as a ground for disconnections.

Leilani Farha (left) and Catarina de Albuquerque (right) listen to questions during a news conference in Detroit, Monday, Oct. 20, 2014.  Credits: AP Photo/Paul Sancya

Leilani Farha (left) and Catarina de Albuquerque (right) listen to questions during a news conference in Detroit, Monday, Oct. 20, 2014.
Credits: AP Photo/Paul Sancya

For her part, Ms. Farha voiced alarm at testimonies of people stating that they had been charged from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department’s “infrastructure deficiencies,” including leakages, as well as the utility’s “lack of competence in dealing with errors in billing or requests for assistance.” Moreover, many residents were not provided with advance warning before their water was shut off and were left without any possibility for administrative recourse.

“In practice, people have no means to prove the errors and hence the bills are impossible to challenge,” Ms. de Albuquerque declared, adding that “the indignity suffered by people whose water was disconnected is unacceptable.”

In particular, Ms. de Albuquerque cited the case of a woman whose water had been cut and whose teenage daughters had to wash themselves with a bottle of water during menstruation. In other instances, she continues, she heard pregnant mothers who feared losing their child because their water was shut off; heads of household who feared losing access to water without any prior notice; others who feared receiving unaffordable and arbitrary water bills.

“Every effort should be made by all levels of government to ensure that the most vulnerable are not evicted from or lose their housing as a result of water shut-offs or water bill arrears,” Ms. Farha concluded.

“The fact that the city is in such a [financial] situation doesn’t exempt it from human rights obligations” Albuquerque added.

Meanwhile, a spokeswoman for Detroit’s Mayor Mike Duggan says the mayor is disappointed by the U.N. report.

In practice, the U.N. does not have the authority to order the city of Detroit to end its water shutoff program nor can it direct the U.S. government to intervene. They hope to work with city and federal officials to seek a solution.


Human Rights
Marco Principia

Born in Rome, his beloved city. Graduated with honors in Political Science and International Relations at Università degli Studi "Roma Tre". Expert of current affairs and United Nations. Recently attended a course in Humanitarian Emergency at INTERSOS. Currently employed at CIES - ONLUS in the Coordination and Organization Office for Interpreting and Translation Service for Territorial Commissions for the Recognition of International Protection. Huge fan of A.S. Roma.
One Comment
  • Quaye Toe Nielam
    24 October 2014 at 2:04 pm
    Leave a Reply

    The government of the United States must financially empower the people that are unable to buy water


  • Leave a Reply




    • Silence

      In a surprising turn of events, the Myanmar military has come forward in a bizarre news conference defending its crackdown on the Rohingya Muslim minority as part of a...
    • Have we forgotten about Eastern Ukraine?

      At the Minsk Summit, on the 11th of February 2015, the leaders of Russia, Ukraine, Germany, and France agreed to an immediate and full ceasefire in the Ukrainian districts...
    • Anti-gay, pro transgender

      Most people would associate Iran and Afghanistan with a religious fundamentalism that goes completely against the realities of transsexuality, transgenderism and homosexuality. And while it is true that both...
    • Jaded

      The failure to effectively regulate the extraction of a country’s natural resources is a policy problem which has ignited and fueled numerous conflicts throughout history. To this day, failure...